In this story a student who attends a Christian school will not be allowed to graduate because he attended the prom with his girlfriend at her public school.
Ohio Christian school tells student to skip prom
Regardless of your personal opinions about dancing, rock music or suggestive clothing, do you think the school has a right or an obligation to be consistent and hold students to the promises they have made?
When believers claim to commit to one specific behavior (whatever it is) then intentionally break that commitment, what is the obligation of the faith community around them? If the school “looks the other way” on this one, would it set a precedent that would prohibit the school from having any integrity if disciplining another student on another area (cheating?) of the student life code?
My personal opinion: This event did not sneak up on this student. Had he taken any steps to change the covenant (appealing to authority in advance) before unilaterally determining to break it? His own words were that he “expected a short lecture..that would be the end of it.” He made a voluntary commitment to a voluntary group. He should be held to the commitments of that group (using progressive loving discipline/restoration) or be removed.
What about the covenant in your small group? If members commit to “not repeat anything shared in the group” and you find that one member is intentionally violating that trust. Does the group have an obligation? Does it just give a short lecture then ignore it?
What do you think?